Are Interest Rates Going Up and Down at the Same Time?
Nest Mortgage • April 8, 2020
If you’re paying more attention to the Canadian economy due to COVID-19, and it seems like you’re getting mixed messages; that mortgage interest rates are going both up and down at the same time, you’re not that far off. There are a lot of moving parts, and to find clarity, we need to make sure we’re comparing apples to apples, and oranges to oranges.
Let’s begin by acknowledging that not all interest rates are the same. The term “interest rates” can mean a lot of different things in news story headlines.
The Government “overnight rate” is different from the “qualifying rate”, which is different from the banks “prime rate”, which is different from “variable rates”, which is different from the “discount on a variable rate” which is different from “fixed rates”.
Here’s a list of the different types of mortgage rates, a quick summary of what they are, the direction they’re going, and how they impact you.
Target for the Overnight Rate.
Also known as the policy rate, this is the rate that the Bank of Canada (The Government) controls. When the Bank of Canada changes the Target for the Overnight Rate, this change affects other interest rates in the economy.
Typically there are only eight days in the year for the Bank of Canada to announce if they will change the rate. However, given the recent COVID-19, the Bank of Canada has made special announcements.
The overnight rate was set with a target of 1.75% for a long time before the pandemic.
March 4th 2020, the rate was lowered to 1.25%.
March 16th 2020, the rate was lowered to 0.75% in an emergency rate cut.
March 27th 2020, the rate was lowered to 0.25% in a second emergency rate cut.
The overnight rate now sits at 0.25% with April 15th 2020, as the next scheduled announcement date.
By cutting interest rates, the government hopes to stimulate economic growth. Lower financing costs encourages borrowing and investing, which is what our government believes will get us through this pandemic.
Qualifying Rate
Also known as the Benchmark Qualifying Rate or the five year qualifying posted rate, this is another rate set by the government. If you’re getting an insured mortgage, the government wants to make sure you will be able to afford your mortgage at the end of your term (in case interest rates go up). So they make you qualify for your mortgage at a higher rate than you will actually be paying.
The government has recently dropped the qualifying rate from 5.19% to 5.04%. This decrease, like the drop in the overnight rate, is meant to help stimulate the economy. The average Canadian will qualify to borrow an additional $10,000 with this drop.
Prime Rate
The banks prime lending rate isn’t the same as the overnight rate; however, the banks prime lending rate is impacted by the overnight rate. Each bank sets its own prime lending rate. When the Bank of Canada moves the overnight rate, typically the prime rate at each bank will follow.
As of the emergency rate cut on March 27th, banks did lower their prime lending rate to 2.45%. Some banks moved immediately, while some made the change effective April 1st, which means the savings will be seen on May 1st, but they all did lower their prime rates.
The prime lending rate is used by banks to determine rates on floating mortgage products (like the variable rate), lines of credit, home equity lines of credit (HELOC), and some credit cards.
If you currently have a variable rate mortgage or a HELOC, a lower prime rate means that you are now paying less interest on your existing mortgage, this is a good thing.
Variable Rate Mortgage
A variable rate mortgage is a mortgage that fluctuates with the prime lending rate. Typically, the mortgage rate will change with the prime lending rate and includes a “component” or “discount” to the prime rate +/- a specified amount, such as Prime - 0.45%. The lender sets this component to prime.
So, if you have a variable rate mortgage at Prime -0.45%, the rate you’d be paying today (with a prime rate of 2.45%) is 2%.
This is where it gets a little confusing because while the government is trying to stimulate the economy by lowering the overnight rate, banks have followed by lowering their prime rate, but at the same time have increased the component to prime - by the same amount 0.5%.
Although there are immediate savings for existing variable rate mortgage holders, anyone looking to get a new variable rate mortgage will do so at a higher rate than a few weeks ago.
Fixed Rate Mortgage
As its name suggests, a fixed rate mortgage is where your mortgage rate stays the same throughout your term. Your rate isn’t tied to the prime lending rate but rather is unmoved by outside factors. With all the uncertainty in the Canadian economy, lenders have actually been increasing rates for new fixed rate mortgages.
So while the government is doing all they can to keep rates low, why are banks increasing fixed rate mortgages?
Well, banks are in the business of making money, and given that over 2 million Canadians have applied for some kind of assistance to get through COVID-19, the fear is that mortgage delinquency will go up considerably as the coronavirus financially impacts people.
Banks are increasing fixed rates to protect themselves against economic uncertainty.
So what does this mean for you? Well, as everyone’s financial situation is different, it’s impossible to give blanket advice that applies to everyone. But here is some general advice.
Existing Variable Rate Holders
You’re doing well. The recent drop in the banks prime rate to 2.45% has lowered the amount of interest you are paying on your mortgage. You have a discount to prime for the remainder of your term that isn’t currently available in the market. Your mortgage rate is one of the lowest in Canadian history.
As the next announcement by the government will be April 15th 2020, there is a chance your rate could go even lower.
If at this time, you’re considering locking your variable rate into a fixed rate, that would significantly increase the amount of interest you are paying. As fixed rates have increased over the last weeks, this isn’t a good option right now.
The reason you went variable in the first place is the reason you should stay variable at this point. With all the economic uncertainty, the prime rate won’t be going up anytime soon.
Existing Fixed Rate Mortgage Holders
Your fixed rate is set lower than the fixed rates currently being offered. If you break your term now, you will incur a higher penalty. So unless you must make a move, it would probably be best just to stay the course.
Hopefully, fixed rates will go down when the economic uncertainty winds down, and rates will be in a good spot when your term comes up for renewal.
Are you looking for a new mortgage?
The most important thing for you going forward is flexibility. Variable rates are still historically low, and although fixed rate mortgages have gone up over the last weeks, there are many great options, maybe a shorter term is a better fit for you?
The best place to start is to contact us directly
so we can go over your financial situation and discuss the best plan for you to move ahead in these uncertain times.
So although it may appear that mortgage interest rates are going both up and down at the same time, understanding what is meant by “interest rates” is crucial. The government is lowering rates to stimulate the economy, while banks are trying to protect themselves against future loses by increasing rates while they can.
BoC (-0.50%) Holiday Rate Cut! 🎄
Who Knew? 🔮 As expected, or easily predicted, the Bank of Canada formally announced a 0.50% cut to the overnight rate earlier this morning. (click for official announcement) This adjusts Prime Rate down to 5.95%, the lowest level we’ve seen in the past two years, and demonstrates a clear signal that the BoC is doing everything possible to kick-start economic growth. A Green Light to Borrow Governor Tiff Macklem’s message is straightforward: borrowing just got cheaper, and more cuts could be coming. With inflation settling back around the 2% target, he’s effectively giving Canadians the go-ahead to take advantage of lower rates, even if average core inflation is still a touch above the goal. "We want to see growth strengthen," Macklem said, and he’s determined to make it happen.
BoC Update | How the Latest BoC Cut Impacts Your Mortgage
Prime Rate will drop from 6.95% to 6.70%.
Specific to variable rate mortgages, the Prime Lending Rate will drop by .25% to 6.95%
As anticipated, this week's Bank of Canada announcement kept the overnight rate unchanged. The Bank expects inflation to hover around 3% and drop below 2.50% later this year, aiming to reach the target of 2% by 2025. Wednesday marked the sixth consecutive "no change" announcement, although speculation persists that we should see rates, specifically Prime, drop by .75-1.00% by the end of 2024. Despite no movement being widely anticipated, it is disappointing that further insight into a housing market reset has now been postponed until the next scheduled decision on June 5th. With unemployment at a 26-month high and GDP underperforming, these are two indicators contradicting the notion of rates remaining "higher for longer".
In light of theIn the wake of today's Bank of Canada (BoC) announcement maintaining the overnight rate at 5.00%, Nest brings you a comprehensive overview of the current mortgage landscape. Prime Rates and payments for variable lending products remain unchanged following this non-rate event, leaving borrowers in a familiar position. While the BoC provided limited insight into the potential timing of interest rate cuts, consensus suggests we might witness the first rate cut materializing in June of this year. Despite the ongoing commitment to restoring price stability for Canadians, a message consistent since July 2023, it is essential to highlight key facets of today's mortgage landscape: 1. GDP: Canada's 4th Quarter (2023) GDP surprised with a 1% annualized growth rate, surpassing expectations. However, beneath the positive headline lies a complex narrative. The growth coincided with a population surge of approximately 430,635 people, equating to a 4% annualized growth rate. On a per capita basis, Canadians appear to be experiencing the intended tightening, a trend persisting in 5 of the last 6 quarters. Per capita GDP adjusted for inflation is now lower than Q4 2014, a noteworthy observation challenging the notion of an economy in need of restraint. 2. Labour: In January, Canada's Labor Force added 37,000 jobs, outperforming expectations, leading to a decline in the unemployment rate to 5.7%. However, a closer examination reveals some finer details. Despite adult population growth of 125,500 people, the labor force expanded by a much smaller 18,200. Additionally, the participation rate for the age group of 15-24 witnessed a concerning decline of 130,000 persons. Without this decline, the unemployment rate would be 0.5% higher. 3. Inflation: Canada's Headline Inflation Number registered below expectations at 2.9%. In the ongoing battle against inflation, there has been significant progress since CPI peaked at 8.1% in June 2022, now comfortably below the 3% threshold. Core measures, though still elevated at 3.4% and 3.3% respectively, are expected to ease further as higher rates prompt more mortgage holders to renew into lower interest rate mortgages. 4. Global Considerations: Economic performance and Bond yields have been influenced by global factors. While global economic growth slowed in the fourth quarter of 2023, U.S. GDP growth remained surprisingly robust and broad-based. Inflation in the U.S. and the Euro area continued to ease, accompanied by a notable rise in equity markets. What's Next? The looming question pertains to the BoC's eventual decision to ease interest rates. The per capita statistics and the intricate state of the Canadian economy are interwoven in unpredictable ways, with the wildcard being the surge in population growth. Inflation, triggered by demand exceeding supply, faces uncertainties on how pent-up demand will respond to rate cuts. The surge in Canada's population, almost double the pre-COVID growth, plays a crucial role in shaping the trajectory of the BoC's decisions. Since October 2023, significant drops in fixed mortgage rates have been observed, likely to persist gradually as markets anticipate rate cuts by the BoC. Current odds indicate at least one rate cut by this summer, and two more to follow before year-end ( market survey ). As we approach the Spring Market, optimism and demand gain momentum. If you've adopted a 'wait and see' approach, now is the opportune moment for a conversation. Preparing before the first rate cut is pivotal, as optimism will inevitably transition to confidence, and housing market activity will return to normal levels. Next BoC Announcement: April 10, 2024.
In light of the softening of the Canadian economy, the Bank of Canada opted to maintain its overnight rate for the fifth consecutive time earlier this month leaving Prime and variable product pricing unchanged. While "financial conditions have eased," the Bank also highlighted persistent inflationary pressures stemming from ongoing wage growth and robust immigration. This is exacerbated by the housing supply failing to keep pace. The Bank continues to emphasize the need for restrictive policy to bring inflation back within target, yet “the market” is no longer buying it! With subdued core inflation pressures, declining GDP and house prices, and a softening labour market, it is inevitable that the Bank will need to reduce rates to avoid severe economic consequences. Market consensus is the rate-tightening cycle has passed and both new and existing mortgage holders can look to much needed rate reprieve in 2024. Bond yields have dipped more than -100bpts since October, leading to lower fixed rates. Conventional 5-year fixed rates are offered at 5.69-5.99%, with a noteworthy offer of 4.99% for default-insured purchases. As fixed rates have only dropped -50bpts over the same period, expect further discounting in the weeks ahead. THE (MORGAGE) YEAR THAT WAS, AND WHAT LIES AHEAD?
Governor Tiff Macklem and the Bank of Canada (BoC) made the expected decision this week: no change to the Overnight Rate [no change to Prime] . While the Bank has surprised markets in the past, this week’s hold was widely anticipated. What makes this instance unique is the growing body of evidence showing that higher interest rates are leaving their mark on the economy... Unprecedented Data Points: Second quarter GDP figures fell significantly below expectations, contracting by 0.2% compared to anticipated growth of 1.2% to 1.5%. Despite substantial population growth, the economy should be thriving, but it's not. Time Lag of Rate Impact: Generally, interest rates take over 12 months to exert their full influence. In the last year, we've seen a total increase of 1.25% in Q2 2022 and another 1.75% in rate hikes in Q3 2022. The July 2023 GDP numbers are showing the impact of these hikes, with sluggish growth. Consumption and Employment Challenges: Total retail sales have plateaued, especially when adjusted per capita, reflecting the weight of higher interest rates on consumer spending. The unemployment rate has climbed by 0.5% in the last three months, further complicating the economic picture. What does this mean for mortgages and rates? Inflation is likely to persist at elevated levels for some time, but it won't prompt the BoC to act unless accompanied by a rebound in GDP growth and spending. As disappointing economic data advances expectations of rate cuts, we may experience downward pressure on fixed interest rates sooner than previously forcasted. Experts are nearing a consensus that the BoC has reached its ceiling on rate tightening, with inflation as the last obstacle before easing. In these uncertain times, we are here to assist. Whether you're considering home buying or refinancing for improved cash flow, we can provide the answers tailored to your needs. Please don't hesitate to reach out to discuss your mortgage needs!
Following weeks of surging rates, Canadian bond yields (which directed impact fixed mortgage rates) have retracted below the 4% threshold, shedding 26 basis points from the previous week's 16-year peak — a potentially temporary but welcome development.